2,798 votes were cast amongst six nominations by Yorkville Patch readers, and Rosati's, 1985 Marketplace Drive, took the pie with 50 percent of the vote.
Maciano's took second place with 22 percent of the vote and Suzy's took third with 14 percent.
Patch readers had this to say about Rosati's, which also won best pizza in 2012:
Kathy T. No one can even come close for the best pie in town! Fresh ingredients, dough made in house every day, everything you want in a great pie!
Pumpkin Patch Best pizza and wings! They are always part of Yorkville events and the parade which makes them even better.
Kandace L. Rosati's is the BEST in the WEST!!!
Jeffery W. Rosati's is by far the best. Nothing else comes close.
Kristin J. Rosatis!!! Just had them last night! Love their pizza!
Thanks to everyone who voted in the poll and left comments for your favorites! Maybe you'll all have somewhere new to check out in the coming weeks?
Stay tuned sometime late next week for our next battle for the best!