2,013 votes have been cast as of Sunday afternoon and four restaurants thus far have a decent chunk of the pie.
Rosati's is in the lead with 41 percent, followed by Maciano's with 28 percent. Suzy's has 17 percent of the vote and Mike and Denise's have claimed 10.
Here's what Patch readers had to say about the current top two:
Rosati'sKathy T. No one can even come close for the best pie in town! Fresh ingredients, dough made in house every day, everything you want in a great pie!
Pumpkin Patch Best pizza and wings! They are always part of Yorkville events and the parade which makes them even better.
Maciano'sBob A. Maciano's pizza is numero uno.
Anyone can still claim a slice of the pie, so be sure to get your vote in!
Voting ends on Thursday, Jan. 9 at 5 p.m.